The speaker, identified as barister ehtasham , begins by sharing two significant pieces of news related to Pakistan, particularly involving Imran Khan and Shah Mahmood Qureshi. The first news is positive, as Imran Khan and Shah Mahmood Qureshi have been granted bail by the Supreme Court in the Cypher case. The Supreme Court bench, headed by Sardar Tariq Masood, included two other judges, Justice Atar Minalla and Justice Mansoor Ali Shah. Justice Mansoor Ali Shah authored the decision, emphasizing that the Official Secrets Act of 1923 is not applicable in this case.
barister ehtasham expresses satisfaction with the Supreme Court’s decision, aligning with his earlier legal opinions shared through vlogs. He argues that the Official Secrets Act cannot be applied in situations like the Cypher case, where Imran Khan faced charges related to national security. He cites examples from history, including the case of martyr Rashid Minhas, to support his stance. The key distinction made by Justice Mansoor Ali Shah in the decision is separating wrongful communication of official documents from the intention to benefit a foreign power.
The speaker highlights that the Supreme Court decision rejects the application of sections related to life imprisonment or death penalty to Imran Khan. He emphasizes that the court found no evidence connecting Imran Khan to the communication of sensitive information for the benefit of a foreign power. The speaker criticizes a previous decision by Chief Justice Amir Farooq of Islamabad High Court, calling it perverse.
Additionally, barister ehtasham mentions a note written by Justice Atar Minalla, a part of the Supreme Court decision. This note connects the Cypher case directly with the 2024 elections in Pakistan. Justice Atar Minalla, according to the speaker, provides a comprehensive analysis of the state of democracy in Pakistan, referencing historical events and expressing concerns about political victimization. The note suggests that the release of Imran Khan and Shah Mahmood Qureshi would ensure genuine elections in Pakistan.
The speaker notes that the media initially reported Justice Atar Minalla’s note along with the decision but later observed its removal from various platforms. He promises to discuss the note in detail in his next vlog. Lastly, Barrister Shah Mameer Uddin briefly mentions another development related to the Election Commission of Pakistan granting relief to Imran Khan in an intra-party matter.
In conclusion, the speaker sees the Supreme Court decision as a significant development in the Cypher case, providing relief to Imran Khan and Shah Mahmood Qureshi. The note by Justice Atar Minalla adds a political dimension, connecting the case with the upcoming elections and expressing concerns about the state of democracy in Pakistan. The removal of the note from media platforms is noted as a noteworthy development
Post Comment